Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Operating Cost by State
Compare annual heating bills for an ENERGY STAR cold-climate heat pump (9.5 HSPF2 / 2.78 seasonal COP) against an 85% AFUE natural gas furnace and electric baseboard resistance heating—calibrated to your state's residential electricity and natural gas rates.
Interactive Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Calculator — United States
Pre-loaded with United States residential utility rates (18.2¢/kWh & $1.48/therm) and mixed climate heating demand.
US baseline: 18.2¢/kWh
US residential baseline: $1.48/therm
Natural Gas Annual Operating Advantage
Gas is $66 / yr cheaper
Vs. electric baseboard resistance heating, a heat pump saves +$1,299/yr ($6,495 over 5 years).
Winter Heat Pump / mo
$146/mo
Winter Gas / mo
$132/mo
5-Yr vs. Gas
-$332
Annual Heating Fuel Cost Comparison (38 MMBtu Delivered)
Heat Pump / MMBtu
$19.16
Gas / MMBtu
$17.41
Break-Even HSPF2
10.5
Break-Even COP
3.06
Estimated annual usage: 4,000 kWh (Heat Pump) vs. 447 therms (Gas Furnace). Operating cost excludes fixed utility meter fees and installation costs.
Top 5 States Where Heat Pumps Beat Natural Gas Most
Highest estimated annual operating savings vs. an 85% AFUE gas furnace
- +$171/yr (15.0¢ · $2.15/th)
- +$135/yr (14.9¢ · $1.64/th)
- +$114/yr (14.4¢ · $1.54/th)
- +$91/yr (15.9¢ · $1.85/th)
- +$89/yr (12.7¢ · $1.56/th)
Top 5 Savings vs. Electric Baseboard / Resistance Heat
Upgrading from 1.0 COP electric resistance heating delivers ~64% lower electricity use
- +$3,619/yr (60 MMBtu load)
- +$3,435/yr (60 MMBtu load)
- +$3,314/yr (60 MMBtu load)
- +$3,229/yr (60 MMBtu load)
- +$3,176/yr (60 MMBtu load)
51-State Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Comparison Table
Sorted by Heat Pump Advantage vs. Natural Gas| Rank | State | Climate / Load | Elec. Rate | Gas Rate | Heat Pump / yr | Gas Furnace / yr | Break-Even COP | HP vs. Gas Diff. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Florida (FL) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 15.0¢/kWh | $2.15/th | $284 | $455 | 1.74 | +$171/yr |
| #2 | North Carolina (NC) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 14.9¢/kWh | $1.64/th | $598 | $733 | 2.27 | +$135/yr |
| #3 | Arkansas (AR) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 14.4¢/kWh | $1.54/th | $575 | $688 | 2.32 | +$114/yr |
| #4 | Georgia (GA) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 15.9¢/kWh | $1.85/th | $301 | $392 | 2.14 | +$91/yr |
| #5 | Nevada (NV) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 12.7¢/kWh | $1.56/th | $241 | $330 | 2.03 | +$89/yr |
| #6 | Washington (WA) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 14.6¢/kWh | $1.48/th | $585 | $662 | 2.46 | +$76/yr |
| #7 | Louisiana (LA) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 12.9¢/kWh | $1.49/th | $244 | $316 | 2.15 | +$72/yr |
| #8 | Tennessee (TN) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 13.4¢/kWh | $1.36/th | $537 | $608 | 2.46 | +$71/yr |
| #9 | Kentucky (KY) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 13.8¢/kWh | $1.38/th | $552 | $617 | 2.49 | +$65/yr |
| #10 | Arizona (AZ) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 15.1¢/kWh | $1.65/th | $285 | $349 | 2.27 | +$64/yr |
| #11 | Alabama (AL) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 16.3¢/kWh | $1.72/th | $309 | $364 | 2.37 | +$55/yr |
| #12 | South Carolina (SC) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 15.8¢/kWh | $1.66/th | $299 | $352 | 2.37 | +$53/yr |
| #13 | Oklahoma (OK) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 14.8¢/kWh | $1.44/th | $593 | $644 | 2.56 | +$51/yr |
| #14 | Oregon (OR) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 15.9¢/kWh | $1.52/th | $637 | $680 | 2.61 | +$43/yr |
| #15 | Mississippi (MS) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 14.4¢/kWh | $1.46/th | $273 | $309 | 2.46 | +$36/yr |
| #16 | Texas (TX) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 15.9¢/kWh | $1.58/th | $301 | $335 | 2.51 | +$33/yr |
| #17 | Virginia (VA) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 17.6¢/kWh | $1.59/th | $706 | $711 | 2.76 | +$5/yr |
| #18 | Nebraska (NE) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 13.5¢/kWh | $1.21/th | $855 | $854 | 2.79 | -$1/yr |
| #19 | Missouri (MO) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 16.0¢/kWh | $1.42/th | $641 | $635 | 2.81 | -$6/yr |
| #20 | Kansas (KS) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 15.5¢/kWh | $1.35/th | $619 | $604 | 2.85 | -$15/yr |
| #21 | Delaware (DE) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 18.7¢/kWh | $1.62/th | $748 | $724 | 2.88 | -$24/yr |
| #22 | West Virginia (WV) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 16.3¢/kWh | $1.41/th | $1,030 | $995 | 2.88 | -$35/yr |
| #23 | Hawaii (HI) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 47.2¢/kWh | $3.90/th | $894 | $826 | 3.01 | -$68/yr |
| #24 | North Dakota (ND) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 13.3¢/kWh | $1.08/th | $841 | $762 | 3.07 | -$78/yr |
| #25 | Utah (UT) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 13.3¢/kWh | $1.06/th | $841 | $748 | 3.13 | -$92/yr |
| #26 | Idaho (ID) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 13.4¢/kWh | $1.05/th | $844 | $741 | 3.17 | -$103/yr |
| #27 | Maryland (MD) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 21.4¢/kWh | $1.66/th | $856 | $742 | 3.21 | -$114/yr |
| #28 | Wyoming (WY) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 14.4¢/kWh | $1.12/th | $911 | $791 | 3.21 | -$121/yr |
| #29 | California (CA) | hot (18 MMBtu) | 29.8¢/kWh | $2.08/th | $564 | $440 | 3.56 | -$123/yr |
| #30 | New Mexico (NM) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 16.5¢/kWh | $1.18/th | $660 | $528 | 3.49 | -$133/yr |
| #31 | South Dakota (SD) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 15.2¢/kWh | $1.14/th | $957 | $805 | 3.31 | -$152/yr |
| #32 | Indiana (IN) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 17.0¢/kWh | $1.26/th | $1,075 | $889 | 3.37 | -$186/yr |
| #33 | Connecticut (CT) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 24.5¢/kWh | $1.92/th | $1,548 | $1,355 | 3.18 | -$193/yr |
| #34 | Montana (MT) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 15.6¢/kWh | $1.09/th | $983 | $769 | 3.56 | -$214/yr |
| #35 | Vermont (VT) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 23.8¢/kWh | $1.82/th | $1,506 | $1,285 | 3.26 | -$221/yr |
| #36 | Iowa (IA) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 17.1¢/kWh | $1.18/th | $1,077 | $833 | 3.60 | -$245/yr |
| #37 | Minnesota (MN) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 17.2¢/kWh | $1.19/th | $1,086 | $840 | 3.60 | -$246/yr |
| #38 | Colorado (CO) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 17.2¢/kWh | $1.15/th | $1,084 | $812 | 3.72 | -$273/yr |
| #39 | District of Columbia (DC) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 26.0¢/kWh | $1.69/th | $1,039 | $756 | 3.83 | -$284/yr |
| #40 | Ohio (OH) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 19.4¢/kWh | $1.32/th | $1,224 | $932 | 3.66 | -$292/yr |
| #41 | Pennsylvania (PA) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 21.8¢/kWh | $1.50/th | $1,375 | $1,059 | 3.62 | -$316/yr |
| #42 | New Jersey (NJ) | mixed (38 MMBtu) | 24.6¢/kWh | $1.44/th | $984 | $644 | 4.26 | -$341/yr |
| #43 | Illinois (IL) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 19.3¢/kWh | $1.24/th | $1,220 | $875 | 3.88 | -$345/yr |
| #44 | Wisconsin (WI) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 19.4¢/kWh | $1.24/th | $1,226 | $875 | 3.90 | -$351/yr |
| #45 | Rhode Island (RI) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 28.2¢/kWh | $1.95/th | $1,780 | $1,376 | 3.60 | -$403/yr |
| #46 | New Hampshire (NH) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 27.6¢/kWh | $1.88/th | $1,746 | $1,327 | 3.66 | -$419/yr |
| #47 | Massachusetts (MA) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 30.5¢/kWh | $2.04/th | $1,925 | $1,440 | 3.72 | -$485/yr |
| #48 | New York (NY) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 28.6¢/kWh | $1.76/th | $1,809 | $1,242 | 4.06 | -$567/yr |
| #49 | Michigan (MI) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 23.0¢/kWh | $1.22/th | $1,452 | $861 | 4.69 | -$591/yr |
| #50 | Maine (ME) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 32.1¢/kWh | $1.98/th | $2,028 | $1,398 | 4.04 | -$630/yr |
| #51 | Alaska (AK) | cold (60 MMBtu) | 29.4¢/kWh | $1.38/th | $1,857 | $974 | 5.31 | -$883/yr |
Reference dataset: U.S. EIA Official Retail Electricity Data (2026-08) & DOE/AFDC Benchmarks (2026-08-EIA-v2). Read full calculation methodology.
Also view EV Charging Cost by State →