HWHomeEnergyCalcs
All 50 US States + Washington, D.C.

Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Operating Cost by State

Compare annual heating bills for an ENERGY STAR cold-climate heat pump (9.5 HSPF2 / 2.78 seasonal COP) against an 85% AFUE natural gas furnace and electric baseboard resistance heating—calibrated to your state's residential electricity and natural gas rates.

Interactive Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Calculator — United States

Pre-loaded with United States residential utility rates (18.2¢/kWh & $1.48/therm) and mixed climate heating demand.

38 MMBtu/yr

US baseline: 18.2¢/kWh

US residential baseline: $1.48/therm

Natural Gas Annual Operating Advantage

Gas is $66 / yr cheaper

Vs. electric baseboard resistance heating, a heat pump saves +$1,299/yr ($6,495 over 5 years).

Winter Heat Pump / mo

$146/mo

Winter Gas / mo

$132/mo

5-Yr vs. Gas

-$332

Annual Heating Fuel Cost Comparison (38 MMBtu Delivered)

Heat Pump (9.5 HSPF2 · COP 2.78)$728/yr
Natural Gas Furnace (85% AFUE)$662/yr
Electric Baseboard / Resistance (1.0 COP)$2,027/yr

Heat Pump / MMBtu

$19.16

Gas / MMBtu

$17.41

Break-Even HSPF2

10.5

Break-Even COP

3.06

Estimated annual usage: 4,000 kWh (Heat Pump) vs. 447 therms (Gas Furnace). Operating cost excludes fixed utility meter fees and installation costs.

Top 5 States Where Heat Pumps Beat Natural Gas Most

Highest estimated annual operating savings vs. an 85% AFUE gas furnace

Top 5 Savings vs. Electric Baseboard / Resistance Heat

Upgrading from 1.0 COP electric resistance heating delivers ~64% lower electricity use

51-State Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Comparison Table

Sorted by Heat Pump Advantage vs. Natural Gas
RankStateClimate / LoadElec. RateGas RateHeat Pump / yrGas Furnace / yrBreak-Even COPHP vs. Gas Diff.
#1Florida (FL)hot (18 MMBtu)15.0¢/kWh$2.15/th$284$4551.74+$171/yr
#2North Carolina (NC)mixed (38 MMBtu)14.9¢/kWh$1.64/th$598$7332.27+$135/yr
#3Arkansas (AR)mixed (38 MMBtu)14.4¢/kWh$1.54/th$575$6882.32+$114/yr
#4Georgia (GA)hot (18 MMBtu)15.9¢/kWh$1.85/th$301$3922.14+$91/yr
#5Nevada (NV)hot (18 MMBtu)12.7¢/kWh$1.56/th$241$3302.03+$89/yr
#6Washington (WA)mixed (38 MMBtu)14.6¢/kWh$1.48/th$585$6622.46+$76/yr
#7Louisiana (LA)hot (18 MMBtu)12.9¢/kWh$1.49/th$244$3162.15+$72/yr
#8Tennessee (TN)mixed (38 MMBtu)13.4¢/kWh$1.36/th$537$6082.46+$71/yr
#9Kentucky (KY)mixed (38 MMBtu)13.8¢/kWh$1.38/th$552$6172.49+$65/yr
#10Arizona (AZ)hot (18 MMBtu)15.1¢/kWh$1.65/th$285$3492.27+$64/yr
#11Alabama (AL)hot (18 MMBtu)16.3¢/kWh$1.72/th$309$3642.37+$55/yr
#12South Carolina (SC)hot (18 MMBtu)15.8¢/kWh$1.66/th$299$3522.37+$53/yr
#13Oklahoma (OK)mixed (38 MMBtu)14.8¢/kWh$1.44/th$593$6442.56+$51/yr
#14Oregon (OR)mixed (38 MMBtu)15.9¢/kWh$1.52/th$637$6802.61+$43/yr
#15Mississippi (MS)hot (18 MMBtu)14.4¢/kWh$1.46/th$273$3092.46+$36/yr
#16Texas (TX)hot (18 MMBtu)15.9¢/kWh$1.58/th$301$3352.51+$33/yr
#17Virginia (VA)mixed (38 MMBtu)17.6¢/kWh$1.59/th$706$7112.76+$5/yr
#18Nebraska (NE)cold (60 MMBtu)13.5¢/kWh$1.21/th$855$8542.79-$1/yr
#19Missouri (MO)mixed (38 MMBtu)16.0¢/kWh$1.42/th$641$6352.81-$6/yr
#20Kansas (KS)mixed (38 MMBtu)15.5¢/kWh$1.35/th$619$6042.85-$15/yr
#21Delaware (DE)mixed (38 MMBtu)18.7¢/kWh$1.62/th$748$7242.88-$24/yr
#22West Virginia (WV)cold (60 MMBtu)16.3¢/kWh$1.41/th$1,030$9952.88-$35/yr
#23Hawaii (HI)hot (18 MMBtu)47.2¢/kWh$3.90/th$894$8263.01-$68/yr
#24North Dakota (ND)cold (60 MMBtu)13.3¢/kWh$1.08/th$841$7623.07-$78/yr
#25Utah (UT)cold (60 MMBtu)13.3¢/kWh$1.06/th$841$7483.13-$92/yr
#26Idaho (ID)cold (60 MMBtu)13.4¢/kWh$1.05/th$844$7413.17-$103/yr
#27Maryland (MD)mixed (38 MMBtu)21.4¢/kWh$1.66/th$856$7423.21-$114/yr
#28Wyoming (WY)cold (60 MMBtu)14.4¢/kWh$1.12/th$911$7913.21-$121/yr
#29California (CA)hot (18 MMBtu)29.8¢/kWh$2.08/th$564$4403.56-$123/yr
#30New Mexico (NM)mixed (38 MMBtu)16.5¢/kWh$1.18/th$660$5283.49-$133/yr
#31South Dakota (SD)cold (60 MMBtu)15.2¢/kWh$1.14/th$957$8053.31-$152/yr
#32Indiana (IN)cold (60 MMBtu)17.0¢/kWh$1.26/th$1,075$8893.37-$186/yr
#33Connecticut (CT)cold (60 MMBtu)24.5¢/kWh$1.92/th$1,548$1,3553.18-$193/yr
#34Montana (MT)cold (60 MMBtu)15.6¢/kWh$1.09/th$983$7693.56-$214/yr
#35Vermont (VT)cold (60 MMBtu)23.8¢/kWh$1.82/th$1,506$1,2853.26-$221/yr
#36Iowa (IA)cold (60 MMBtu)17.1¢/kWh$1.18/th$1,077$8333.60-$245/yr
#37Minnesota (MN)cold (60 MMBtu)17.2¢/kWh$1.19/th$1,086$8403.60-$246/yr
#38Colorado (CO)cold (60 MMBtu)17.2¢/kWh$1.15/th$1,084$8123.72-$273/yr
#39District of Columbia (DC)mixed (38 MMBtu)26.0¢/kWh$1.69/th$1,039$7563.83-$284/yr
#40Ohio (OH)cold (60 MMBtu)19.4¢/kWh$1.32/th$1,224$9323.66-$292/yr
#41Pennsylvania (PA)cold (60 MMBtu)21.8¢/kWh$1.50/th$1,375$1,0593.62-$316/yr
#42New Jersey (NJ)mixed (38 MMBtu)24.6¢/kWh$1.44/th$984$6444.26-$341/yr
#43Illinois (IL)cold (60 MMBtu)19.3¢/kWh$1.24/th$1,220$8753.88-$345/yr
#44Wisconsin (WI)cold (60 MMBtu)19.4¢/kWh$1.24/th$1,226$8753.90-$351/yr
#45Rhode Island (RI)cold (60 MMBtu)28.2¢/kWh$1.95/th$1,780$1,3763.60-$403/yr
#46New Hampshire (NH)cold (60 MMBtu)27.6¢/kWh$1.88/th$1,746$1,3273.66-$419/yr
#47Massachusetts (MA)cold (60 MMBtu)30.5¢/kWh$2.04/th$1,925$1,4403.72-$485/yr
#48New York (NY)cold (60 MMBtu)28.6¢/kWh$1.76/th$1,809$1,2424.06-$567/yr
#49Michigan (MI)cold (60 MMBtu)23.0¢/kWh$1.22/th$1,452$8614.69-$591/yr
#50Maine (ME)cold (60 MMBtu)32.1¢/kWh$1.98/th$2,028$1,3984.04-$630/yr
#51Alaska (AK)cold (60 MMBtu)29.4¢/kWh$1.38/th$1,857$9745.31-$883/yr

Reference dataset: U.S. EIA Official Retail Electricity Data (2026-08) & DOE/AFDC Benchmarks (2026-08-EIA-v2). Read full calculation methodology.

Also view EV Charging Cost by State →