Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Operating Cost in Indiana
Indiana's baseline residential natural gas rate is $1.26/therm (15% below the US average), compared with 17.0¢/kWh for residential electricity. Enter your utility rates and home heating load below to model your exact winter operating costs.
IN Electricity & Gas
17.0¢ · $1.26
¢/kWh vs. $/therm residential rate
Cost per Delivered MMBtu
$17.92 vs. $14.82
Heat pump (9.5 HSPF2) vs. 85% gas
Break-Even Efficiency
COP 3.37
Equal to 11.5 HSPF2 vs. 85% AFUE
Est. Annual Savings vs. Gas
-$186/yr
Saves $1,918/yr vs. resistance
Interactive Heat Pump vs. Gas Furnace Calculator — Indiana
Pre-loaded with Indiana residential utility rates (17.0¢/kWh & $1.26/therm) and cold climate heating demand.
IN baseline: 17.0¢/kWh
IN residential baseline: $1.26/therm
Natural Gas Annual Operating Advantage
Gas is $184 / yr cheaper
Vs. electric baseboard resistance heating, a heat pump saves +$1,916/yr ($9,579 over 5 years).
Winter Heat Pump / mo
$215/mo
Winter Gas / mo
$178/mo
5-Yr vs. Gas
-$921
Annual Heating Fuel Cost Comparison (60 MMBtu Delivered)
Heat Pump / MMBtu
$17.89
Gas / MMBtu
$14.82
Break-Even HSPF2
11.5
Break-Even COP
3.36
Estimated annual usage: 6,316 kWh (Heat Pump) vs. 706 therms (Gas Furnace). Operating cost excludes fixed utility meter fees and installation costs.
Indiana Annual Heating Cost by Home Size (cold climate)
Compares a cold-climate 9.5 HSPF2 air-source heat pump, an 85% AFUE natural gas furnace, and 1.0 COP electric resistance heating at Indiana's baseline rates.
| Home Size & Load | Heat Pump (9.5 HSPF2) | Gas Furnace (85% AFUE) | Electric Baseboard | Heat Pump vs. Gas |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small Home / Condo (1,400 sq ft) (42 MMBtu) | $752/yr | $623/yr | $2,095/yr | Gas -$130/yr |
| Typical Home (2,000 sq ft) (60 MMBtu) | $1,075/yr | $889/yr | $2,993/yr | Gas -$186/yr |
| Large Home (2,800 sq ft) (84 MMBtu) | $1,505/yr | $1,245/yr | $4,190/yr | Gas -$260/yr |
Reference dataset: U.S. EIA Official Retail Electricity Data (2026-08) & DOE/AFDC Benchmarks (2026-08-EIA-v2). View thermodynamic formulas and assumptions.
Climate & Dual-Fuel Insights for Indiana
Cold-climate inverter air-source heat pumps maintain efficient heat output well below freezing (down to 5°F or -15°F), though seasonal COP drops during extreme sub-zero snaps. Properly sizing equipment and air-sealing ductwork prevents expensive electric resistance backup strips from running excessively.
Note: Homeowners switching away from gas entirely also eliminate year-round fixed monthly gas utility connection fees ($15–$30/mo in many markets), which adds $180–$360 in annual savings not included in fuel-only operating figures above.
More Indiana Energy Tools
Charging an Electric Car at Home in Indiana?
Compare 17.0¢/kWh overnight home EV charging against $3.16/gal gasoline.
Frequently Asked Questions — Indiana Heat Pumps
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace in Indiana?
At standard flat utility rates (17.0¢/kWh vs. $1.26/therm), an 85% AFUE gas furnace currently runs about $186/year less than a 9.5 HSPF2 heat pump. To beat natural gas purely on operating cost in Indiana, a heat pump needs a seasonal COP above 3.37 (11.5 HSPF2) or pairing with rooftop solar.
What heat pump efficiency (COP / HSPF2) breaks even with natural gas in Indiana?
Using Indiana's baseline residential utility rates and an 85% AFUE reference furnace, the fuel-cost break-even point is 11.5 HSPF2 (seasonal COP of 3.37). Whenever your heat pump operates above COP 3.37, it costs less per BTU delivered than burning natural gas.
How much does a heat pump save over electric baseboard heat in Indiana?
Switching from 100%-efficient (1.0 COP) electric baseboard or resistance furnace heat to a 9.5 HSPF2 (2.78 COP) heat pump reduces heating electricity usage by roughly 64%, saving an estimated $1,918/year ($9,590 over 5 years) at Indiana's 17.0¢/kWh rate.